top of page

Myomectomy vs Hysterectomy for Fibroids

Updated: Mar 26



Welcome to our in-depth guide on managing uterine fibroids, a condition that affects countless women but can be navigated with the right information and choices. For those looking to preserve their fertility, a myomectomy for fibroids offers a promising solution; it meticulously removes only the fibroids, aiming to keep the uterus intact for future possibilities of pregnancy. On the other hand, if pregnancy isn't in your plans, a hysterectomy might emerge as the more fitting option, providing a definitive end to fibroid troubles.


However, treatment choices come with their considerations. Potential risks such as excessive blood loss, infections requiring antibiotic treatment, the development of scar tissue, and complications during childbirth are aspects to be aware of. This guide also delves into treatment efficacy for fibroids that are larger than 10cm and intramural subtype (lying within the uterine muscle), where both myomectomy and Uterine Fibroid Embolisation (UFE) stand as equally effective options.


While myomectomy and UFE offer substantial relief, it's important to understand that myomectomy, focusing on removing only your fibroids, is not necessarily a one-time solution for all. Particularly with abdominal approaches, there was little difference in outcomes, emphasising that myomectomy, despite being a focused surgical removal of uterine fibroids without opting for a hysterectomy, requires thoughtful consideration.


Through this article, we aim to shed the light on the nuanced decisions surrounding fibroid treatment, offering clarity and support for those navigating this journey. Whether you're leaning towards a private myomectomy for fibroids for its fertility-preserving qualities or considering other options based on your personal health goals, our guide is here to provide you with the insights you need to make informed decisions about private treatment for fibroids in London.


Understanding Fibroids


Fibroids are benign tumours that grow within the muscle tissue of the uterus, a condition affecting up to 80% of women by the age of 50. While the exact cause of fibroids remains a topic of ongoing research, factors such as hormones and genetic predispositions play significant roles. Not all women with fibroids experience symptoms, but for those who do, the impact can range from mild to severely disruptive, affecting daily activities and overall health.


Symptoms of fibroids can include heavy menstrual bleeding, pelvic pain, frequent urination, and complications during pregnancy and labour. The diagnosis of fibroids typically involves a pelvic examination, followed by imaging tests such as ultrasound or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to confirm their presence, size, and location.

Our clinic specialises in advanced gynaecology scanning, a crucial step in diagnosing and planning the treatment for fibroids. Our state-of-the-art diagnostic tools allow for a comprehensive assessment, ensuring that each patient receives the most appropriate and effective treatment plan. Understanding the nature of your fibroids is the first step towards reclaiming your health and well-being.


Is hysterectomy the only cure for fibroids?


While hysterectomy is a definitive cure for fibroids, it is not the only treatment option. It completely eliminates the chance of fibroid recurrence by removing the uterus. However, other treatments, such as myomectomy, can effectively manage fibroids by removing them while preserving the uterus, and UFE (Uterine Fibroid Embolisation) can significantly reduce their size and symptoms. The choice of treatment should be based on a comprehensive evaluation of the patient's condition and discussions about their personal and reproductive health goals.


Is it better to have a hysterectomy or myomectomy?


The choice between a hysterectomy and myomectomy largely depends on the individual's circumstances, including age, fertility desires, and the severity of fibroid symptoms. Myomectomy is generally preferred for women who wish to preserve their fertility and uterus, as it involves removing only the fibroids. Hysterectomy, the removal of the uterus, offers a permanent solution to fibroid-related symptoms but ends the ability to conceive and is typically recommended for women who do not plan to have children in the future or who have significant symptoms that drastically impact their quality of life.


Which operation is better for fibroids?


The "better" operation for fibroids is subjective and varies per individual case. Myomectomy is often recommended for women seeking to maintain fertility and for those with fewer or less severe fibroids. Hysterectomy may be considered better for women who have completed their families or suffer from severe symptoms that significantly affect their life, offering a definitive end to fibroid issues. The best course of action is determined through a thorough evaluation of the patient's health status, fibroid characteristics, and personal health goals.


Is it better to shrink fibroids or to surgically remove them?


Shrinking fibroids through medication or procedures like Uterine Fibroid Embolisation (UFE) can be an effective treatment for women seeking a less invasive option or for those whose fibroids are not causing severe symptoms. Surgical removal, either via myomectomy or hysterectomy, might be better for providing immediate relief from symptoms, especially in cases of large or multiple fibroids. The choice between shrinking and removing fibroids depends on the patient's symptoms, fibroid size, location, and personal preferences regarding treatment invasiveness and fertility concerns.


Treatment options overview


When it comes to addressing fibroids, modern medicine offers several pathways, each tailored to the unique needs and health objectives of the individual. At our clinic, nestled in the vibrant heart of Central London, we prioritise a patient-centred approach, ensuring you're fully informed of all available treatments. Among these, myomectomy and hysterectomy stand out as primary surgical options, with uterine fibroid Embolisation (UFE) providing a non-surgical alternative worth considering.


Myomectomy


Myomectomy is often the preferred choice for women wishing to preserve their uterus and fertility potential. This surgical procedure involves the removal of fibroids, aiming to alleviate symptoms while maintaining the integrity of the uterus. It's particularly suited to women who plan to conceive or who wish to keep their uterus for personal reasons. The method of myomectomy varies- ranging from abdominal, laparoscopic, robotic or hysteroscopic, depending on the size, location, and number of fibroids.


Hysterectomy


Hysterectomy on the other hand, is the surgical removal of the uterus, offering a permanent solution to fibroid-related symptoms. This procedure is generally recommended when other treatments have failed, fibroids are particularly large, or when the patient expresses no desire to maintain fertility. While it conclusively addresses the issue of fibroids, the decision to undergo a hysterectomy is profound, affecting a woman's reproductive capabilities.


Uterine Fibroid Embolisation (UFE)


Uterine Fibroid Embolisation (UFE) represents a minimally invasive alternative, targeting fibroids through the blocking of their blood supply. This procedure is an option for those seeking a non-surgical approach to reduce fibroid size and alleviate symptoms without removing the uterus or fibroids directly. UFE can be an excellent choice for patients prioritising a shorter recovery time and fewer surgical risks.


Our clinic is uniquely positioned to offer these treatments, backed by advanced diagnostic imaging and a team fluent in both the complexities of gynaecological health and the nuances of patient care. Our commitment to providing a one-stop solution for gynaecological needs, coupled with our capability to conduct advanced gynaecology scanning in-house, sets us apart. We understand the intricacies of fibroid treatment and are dedicated to guiding you through your options with compassion and expertise, ensuring the path you choose aligns with your health goals and life plans.


Myomectomy: a closer look


In the pursuit of excellence in women's healthcare, our clinic offers a nuanced understanding and application of myomectomy procedures, tailored to the specific needs and health objectives of our patients. Myomectomy stands as a beacon of hope for those who wish to alleviate the discomfort of fibroids while preserving fertility and the integrity of the uterus. Our approach is grounded in the latest advancements in gynaecological care, ensuring you receive the most effective, personalised treatment.


Overview and types


Abdominal myomectomy


Abdominal myomectomy is a traditional surgical method, ideal for removing large or deeply embedded fibroids. This procedure requires an incision in the lower abdomen, through which the fibroids are excised. Despite its invasiveness, it allows for direct access and the removal of substantial fibroid masses, offering a thorough solution for severe cases.


Laparoscopic or robotic myomectomy


Laparoscopic or robotic myomectomy represents the pinnacle of surgical innovation, offering a minimally invasive alternative. Through small incisions, specialised instruments and a camera are inserted, allowing for precise fibroid removal with minimal disruption to surrounding tissues. The robotic variant enhances this precision further, affording the surgeon superior control and vision. These methods significantly reduce recovery time, minimise scarring, and maintain uterine integrity for future pregnancies.


Hysteroscopic myomectomy


Hysteroscopic myomectomy is the least invasive option, suitable for fibroids located within the uterine cavity. A small instrument is introduced through the vagina and cervix, requiring no abdominal incisions. This technique is particularly effective for submucosal fibroids, offering a quick recovery and minimal complications.


Pros and cons of myomectomy


Each myomectomy method comes with its distinct advantages and considerations. Abdominal myomectomy, while comprehensive, involves a longer recovery and greater postoperative discomfort. Laparoscopic and robotic techniques, though less invasive, may not be suitable for all fibroid sizes and locations but offer the benefit of quicker recovery and less postoperative pain. Hysteroscopic myomectomy, focusing on internal uterine fibroids, provides a targeted solution with the least impact on the body's overall structure and the fastest return to daily activities.


Ideal candidates for myomectomy


The ideal candidates for myomectomy are women who wish to remove fibroids due to discomfort or reproductive interference while preserving their uterus. Those prioritising fertility or seeking relief from fibroid symptoms without the finality of a hysterectomy may find myomectomy a fitting choice. Our clinic's advanced diagnostic capabilities, including in-house gynaecology scanning, enable us to determine the most suitable myomectomy method for each patient, considering fibroid characteristics and personal health goals.


Hysterectomy: A closer look


At the core of our clinic's philosophy is a commitment to offering choices that align with our patients' health and personal aspirations. Understanding that the journey through gynaecological health is profoundly personal, we approach the topic of hysterectomy with sensitivity, expertise, and a focus on individual needs. As a definitive solution to fibroid-related symptoms, hysterectomy is a procedure that requires careful consideration and comprehensive support.


Overview of hysterectomy


Hysterectomy, the surgical removal of the uterus, presents a permanent solution to the challenges posed by fibroids. This procedure effectively eliminates the possibility of fibroid recurrence, bringing an end to symptoms such as heavy menstrual bleeding, pelvic pain, and the risk of anaemia. While it marks the cessation of fertility, it offers relief and a new lease on life for many women.


Our clinic, situated in the vibrant heart of Central London, is equipped with advanced surgical technologies and expertise, ensuring that those who choose hysterectomy receive the highest standard of care. Our approach is holistic, addressing not just the physical aspects of the procedure but also the emotional and psychological impacts, supporting our patients through every step of their journey.


Pros and cons of hysterectomy


Pros


- Eliminates fibroids permanently, preventing recurrence.

- Ends fibroid-related symptoms, improving quality of life.

- May be beneficial in cases where other treatments have failed or are not viable.


Cons


- Ends the ability to conceive, which is a significant consideration for women of childbearing age.

- Requires a recovery period, with the length and intensity varying based on the surgical approach (abdominal, laparoscopic, or vaginal).

- Like any major surgery, it carries risks such as infection, bleeding, and reactions to anaesthesia.


When is a hysterectomy considered the best option?


Hysterectomy is typically considered when other treatments have not provided relief, when fibroids are large or rapidly growing, or when they cause significant symptoms affecting a woman's quality of life. It is also a viable option for women who are certain they do not wish to bear children in the future and are looking for a permanent solution.


Our clinic takes pride in our advanced gynaecology scanning capabilities and our ability to offer personalised care. We ensure that every patient understands their options fully and receives guidance tailored to their unique situation. For those for whom hysterectomy is the best path forward, our team provides comprehensive care, from pre-surgical consultation to post-operative recovery support, all within the comfort of our state-of-the-art facility.


Our commitment to excellence in gynaecological care, coupled with our unique selling points- such as our location, bilingual staff, and association with reputable NHS hospitals—ensures that our patients receive not only the best clinical care but also a supportive and understanding environment.


Comparative analysis of myomectomy vs hysterectomy


In guiding our patients through their treatment journey, we emphasise informed choice, leveraging our clinic's unique strengths- advanced diagnostic capabilities, personalised care, and a comprehensive range of treatment options. This comparative analysis of myomectomy and hysterectomy, alongside a brief mention of Uterine Fibroid Embolisation (UFE), is designed to illuminate the path to the best possible health outcomes.


Myomectomy vs hysterectomy: which is more invasive?


Myomectomy offers a range of surgical options, each varying in invasiveness, to cater to the diverse needs of our patients. The abdominal myomectomy is the most traditional form, involving a more significant incision to access and remove fibroids. This method is typically reserved for cases where fibroids are large or numerous.


On the other end of the spectrum, hysteroscopic myomectomy stands as the least invasive option, performed through the vagina and cervix, targeting fibroids located within the uterine cavity without the need for external incisions. Laparoscopic and robotic myomectomies find their place in the middle, offering a minimally invasive alternative through small abdominal incisions. These techniques employ advanced surgical instruments and cameras to remove fibroids with precision, minimising tissue disruption and facilitating a quicker recovery.


Hysterectomy, akin to myomectomy, encompasses various techniques reflecting different levels of invasiveness. The abdominal approach, while offering a comprehensive solution to fibroids, is the most invasive, requiring a longer recovery period. In contrast, laparoscopic and vaginal hysterectomies present less invasive alternatives, utilising smaller incisions or no abdominal incisions, respectively. These methods significantly reduce the recovery time and physical impact on the patient, aligning with our clinic's dedication to minimising patient discomfort and facilitating a swift return to daily life.


Myomectomy vs hysterectomy: which has a longer hospital stay and shorter recovery time?


Myomectomy patients experience varying lengths of hospital stay and recovery times, depending on the surgical approach chosen. For those undergoing an abdominal myomectomy, a stay of 1-2 days in the hospital is typical, reflecting the more invasive nature of the procedure. The subsequent recovery period, spanning 2-4 weeks, allows for healing and gradual return to normal activities.


Conversely, laparoscopic and hysteroscopic myomectomies often permit same-day discharge, underscoring the less invasive techniques and the advanced surgical practices employed by our clinic. The recovery from these methods is notably quicker, generally ranging from a few days to 2 weeks, enabling patients to resume their daily routines with minimal delay.


Hysterectomy involves a slightly longer hospital stay and recovery period, particularly for the abdominal approach, which typically requires a 2-3 day hospital stay. The comprehensive nature of this procedure, aiming to provide a permanent solution to fibroid-related symptoms, necessitates a recovery span of 4-6 weeks. This time frame allows for complete healing and adjustment post-surgery. However, our clinic's adoption of laparoscopic/robotic hysterectomies offers patients the advantage of reduced hospital stays and faster recovery times. These minimally invasive options can significantly shorten the recovery process, facilitating a quicker return to well-being and everyday life.


Safety of myomectomy vs hysterectomy: side effects & complications?


Myomectomy is renowned for its ability to remove fibroids while preserving the uterus, making it a preferred option for many women. However, like all surgical procedures, it carries certain risks. Bleeding and infection are among the primary concerns, necessitating meticulous surgical technique and post-operative care to minimise these risks. Additionally, there is a potential for damage to surrounding organs, a risk that underscores the importance of choosing experienced surgeons, like those at our clinic, who are adept at navigating the complexities of such procedures. Our advanced imaging technologies further mitigate these risks by providing detailed pre-operative planning to ensure precision and safety.


Hysterectomy, offering a definitive resolution to fibroid-related symptoms by removing the uterus, shares similar risks with myomectomy, including bleeding and infection. An additional consideration for hysterectomy patients is the potential for hormonal changes, particularly if the ovaries are also removed during the procedure. These hormonal changes can have significant impacts on a woman's body, potentially necessitating hormone replacement therapy. Our clinic's holistic approach to care includes comprehensive pre-surgical counselling and post-operative support to navigate these changes, ensuring that patients feel supported and informed throughout their journey.


Myomectomy vs hysterectomy: which has a greater impact on fertility?


The decision to undergo treatment for fibroids often intersects with a woman's reproductive plans, making the impact on fertility a critical consideration. Our clinic approaches this sensitive topic with the utmost care, ensuring our patients are equipped with the knowledge to make decisions that align with their fertility goals.


Myomectomy is heralded as the option that best preserves fertility, making it an attractive choice for women who wish to conceive in the future. This procedure involves the surgical removal of fibroids while leaving the uterus intact, thereby maintaining the patient's ability to carry a pregnancy. Many women who undergo myomectomy successfully conceive and have healthy pregnancies post-treatment. Our team of specialists provides comprehensive follow-up care to support women in their journey toward motherhood, offering advice and assistance to optimise fertility outcomes.


Hysterectomy, by contrast, eliminates the possibility of pregnancy by removing the uterus. This procedure is typically considered when other treatments have failed or are deemed unsuitable, or when the patient has decided against future pregnancies. Understanding the permanence of this decision, our clinic offers extensive counselling to ensure that patients feel supported and confident in their choice. For women who undergo a hysterectomy, we provide guidance on alternative paths to parenthood, should they wish to explore them, such as surrogacy or adoption.


Myomectomy vs hysterectomy: which carries the greater risk of fibroid recurrence?


Our clinic's comprehensive approach to patient care encompasses a thorough discussion of these risks, ensuring that every treatment plan is crafted with both immediate and future health in mind.


Myomectomy represents a great hope for many women seeking relief from fibroid symptoms while preserving their uterus. However, it's important to acknowledge that myomectomy, despite its benefits, carries a risk of fibroid recurrence. The nature of fibroids means that new growths can develop over time, potentially necessitating additional treatment. Our clinic is dedicated to ongoing care and monitoring post-myomectomy, providing guidance on lifestyle adjustments and medical therapies that may reduce the likelihood of recurrence and supporting patients through any further treatments should they become necessary.


Hysterectomy offers a definitive solution to the challenge of fibroids, completely eliminating the risk of recurrence by removing the uterus. This procedure is often considered in more severe cases or when a woman has completed her family. While it brings a sense of finality to the issue of fibroids, our clinic ensures that the decision to proceed with a hysterectomy is made with full understanding and consent, considering all the implications for the patient's health and lifestyle.


In all cases, our clinic emphasises the importance of personalised care and informed decision-making. We provide detailed follow-up and support for all our patients, regardless of the treatment path chosen, ensuring that every woman feels confident and supported in managing her health over the long term. Our approach is rooted in the understanding that treatment for fibroids is not just about addressing the immediate issue but about ensuring ongoing health and well-being for all our patients.


Myomectomy vs Hysterectomy: navigating your decision


Choosing the most suitable treatment option for fibroids- a decision that intertwines with one's health, well-being, and future plans requires careful consideration of various factors. At our clinic, we are committed to empowering our patients with knowledge and support, guiding them through this decision-making process with compassion and expertise. Here, we explore the critical factors to consider when weighing the options between myomectomy and hysterectomy, and the pivotal role of advanced gynaecology scanning in this journey.


Myomectomy vs hysterectomy: main factors to consider


Future family plans: One of the most significant considerations is whether you wish to have children in the future. Myomectomy is often the preferred option for women who want to preserve their fertility, as it involves removing fibroids while leaving the uterus intact. On the other hand, a hysterectomy ends the ability to conceive naturally, making it a decision that requires profound consideration, particularly for women in their reproductive years.


Symptom severity and fibroid characteristics: the size, number, and location of fibroids can influence the choice of treatment. Myomectomy might be more suitable for women with fewer or smaller fibroids, while a hysterectomy may be recommended for those with extensive fibroid growth that significantly impacts quality of life.


Desire for a definitive solution: for women seeking a permanent solution to fibroid-related symptoms, a hysterectomy offers finality, eliminating the risk of recurrence. This option might appeal to those who have completed their families or for whom fibroids severely impair their quality of life.


Personal health and medical history: individual health considerations, including previous surgeries and overall medical history, can affect the choice of treatment. Our clinic's specialists carefully evaluate these factors to recommend the most appropriate and safe treatment option.


The Role of advanced gynaecology scanning in determining the best option


Advanced gynaecology scanning stands at the forefront of our decision-making process. This cutting-edge technology allows for a detailed assessment of the uterus and fibroids, providing invaluable information on their size, number, and precise location. Such detailed imaging is crucial in determining the feasibility of myomectomy, assessing the potential for preserving fertility, and identifying the most effective surgical approach. Similarly, for those considering a hysterectomy, scanning provides insights into the extent of fibroid impact and other uterine conditions that may influence the decision.


Our clinic's commitment to utilising the latest in diagnostic imaging reflects our dedication to personalised care. By offering a clear picture of each patient's unique situation, advanced gynaecology scanning ensures that the chosen treatment path is tailored to the individual's specific needs, optimising outcomes and patient satisfaction.


In navigating your decision between myomectomy and hysterectomy, our clinic provides a supportive environment where your concerns and aspirations are heard. With our expertise and the aid of advanced diagnostic tools, we aim to empower you to make a choice that aligns with your health goals and life plans, ensuring you feel confident and informed every step of the way.


Our clinic's approach to fibroid treatment


At Rylon Clinic, nestled in the vibrant heart of Central London, we pride ourselves on offering a comprehensive and holistic approach to fibroid treatment. Our methodology is built upon the pillars of innovation, personalised care, and inclusivity, ensuring that every woman who walks through our doors receives the highest standard of care tailored to her unique needs.


One-stop gynaecology clinic


We understand the value of convenience and efficiency in healthcare. That's why Rylon Clinic has been designed as a one-stop solution for all gynaecological needs, especially for the management and treatment of fibroids. From initial consultation through to diagnostic scans, treatment, and follow-up care, our patients benefit from a seamless and integrated care pathway, all under one roof. This approach not only saves time but also reduces the stress associated with managing health concerns, allowing our patients to focus on their recovery and well-being.


Advanced scanning capabilitie


Central to our clinic's approach is our investment in state-of-the-art gynaecological scanning technology. Our advanced diagnostic capabilities enable us to provide detailed assessments of fibroids, offering insights into their size, type, and impact with unparalleled precision. This level of diagnostic detail is crucial for crafting the most effective treatment plans, whether that involves surgical intervention, such as myomectomy or hysterectomy, or minimally invasive options like UFE. By leveraging these advanced scanning technologies, we ensure that each patient receives a treatment plan optimised for her specific condition, maximising the chances of successful outcomes.


The importance of individualised care


At the heart of Rylon Clinic's philosophy is a deep commitment to individualised care. We recognize that each patient's journey with fibroids is unique, influenced by her health goals, personal circumstances, and future plans. Our team of experts takes the time to listen to each patient, understand her needs, and tailor our approach accordingly. This personalised care extends beyond medical treatment to include support for emotional well-being, lifestyle adjustments, and long-term health planning.


Rylon Clinic's approach to fibroid treatment encapsulates our dedication to excellence, innovation, and patient-centred care. By combining our one-stop clinic convenience, advanced diagnostic tools, bilingual support, and individualised care ethos, we not only meet but exceed our patients' expectations. Our goal is not just to treat fibroids but to enhance our patients' quality of life, empowering them to make informed decisions about their health and future.


Through this dedicated approach, we aim to uphold and advance our clinic's reputation as a leader in gynaecological care, continually striving to achieve the best possible outcomes for our patients while contributing to their overall well-being and satisfaction.


Conclusion


Navigating the complexities of fibroid treatment requires careful consideration of various factors, including the impact on fertility, the invasiveness of treatment options, and the potential for recurrence. At Rylon Clinic, we prioritise a patient-centred approach, offering advanced diagnostic capabilities, bilingual support, and a commitment to individualised care to guide each woman through her treatment journey.


- Myomectomy presents a fertility-preserving option suitable for women wishing to maintain the possibility of pregnancy, offering a tailored approach to fibroid removal.

- Hysterectomy provides a definitive solution for those seeking relief from fibroid symptoms, recommended for women who are not planning future pregnancies.

- Uterine Fibroid Embolisation (UFE) offers a minimally invasive alternative, reducing symptoms and fibroid size with a variable impact on future fertility.


Choosing the right treatment involves weighing these options against personal health goals and lifestyle considerations. Rylon Clinic stands ready to support you through this process, offering the latest in treatment technologies within a caring and supportive environment.


Author: Mr Osama Naji


Mr Naji offers a “one-stop” gynaecology clinic for instant detection of various gynaecological cancers as well as providing all the diagnostic and treatment services needed under one roof.



Mr Naji provides advanced gynaecology scanning which is essential when conducting any gynaecology consultation, he is bilingual in English and Arabic and has an NHS base at the highly reputable Guy's and St Thomas' Hospital in London.

He is passionate about raising awareness of various subtle signs and symptoms of gynaecological conditions that are often overlooked by patients.

You can read more about Mr Naji on his about page here.


Comments


bottom of page